Close Menu
    SUBSCRIBE
    Stargazy Pie Recipe
    Stargazy Pie Recipe
    Drink

    Stargazy Pie Recipe, A Legendary Cornish Delight That Tells a Story

    Sam AllcockBy Updated:235 Comments4 Mins Read

    Stargazy Pie is one of those foods that captivates you before you even taste it. With whole fish heads “gazing at the stars” piercing its golden pastry crust, this classic Cornish recipe is a visual feast and a table display. This dish is a perennial favorite in Cornwall because it honors community, resiliency, and culinary inventiveness.

    Stargazy Pie’s beginnings are legendary. The dish is associated with the Cornish fishing village of Mousehole’s Tom Bawcock’s Eve celebration. According to legend, the village faced starvation during a severe winter in the 16th century because storms prevented fishermen from venturing out to sea. Tom Bawcock bravely stepped into the dangerous waters and came back with a bountiful haul. Since the entire village was fed by the fish baked into a savory pie, Stargazy Pie has stood for tenacity and thankfulness.

    Key Information About Stargazy Pie

    CategoryDetails
    OriginCornwall, England
    First Appearance16th Century
    Cultural SignificanceCelebrated in Mousehole every December 23rd on “Tom Bawcock’s Eve”
    Main IngredientsMackerel (or sardines), bacon, eggs, pastry, white wine, saffron, cream
    Unique FeatureWhole fish heads poking through the crust
    Ideal PairingsBoiled new potatoes, green vegetables, crisp white wine
    Official Recipe Reference🔗 Visit Here

    How to Prepare Real Stargazy Pie

    With its flaky puff pastry crust, smoky bacon, fresh fish, and a creamy sauce infused with saffron, this recipe remains faithful to its Cornish origins. Don’t worry—the fish bones have been removed, making it simple to eat and savor. The dramatic presentation is part of the appeal.

    🛒 Ingredients

    For the Filling

    ✔️ 30g (1oz) butter
    ✔️ 1 onion, finely chopped
    ✔️ 1 leek, finely chopped
    ✔️ 3 rashers smoked or unsmoked streaky bacon, finely chopped
    ✔️ 20g (¾oz) plain flour
    ✔️ 3 tbsp dry white wine
    ✔️ 250ml (9fl oz) fish stock
    ✔️ 300ml (10fl oz) double cream
    ✔️ A pinch of saffron strands
    ✔️ 1 tsp salt
    ✔️ Small bunch of fresh parsley, chopped
    ✔️ 2 hard-boiled eggs, chopped
    ✔️ 6 small mackerel, butterflied (heads on, backbone and tail removed)
    ✔️ Freshly ground black pepper

    For the Pastry

    ✔️ 200g (7oz) puff pastry
    ✔️ 1 free-range egg, beaten (for glaze)

    To Serve

    ✔️ Boiled new potatoes
    ✔️ Steamed green vegetables

    👨‍🍳 Step-by-Step Cooking Method

    1️⃣ Prepare the Filling

    1️⃣ Preheat the oven to 200°C (180°C Fan) / Gas Mark 6.
    2️⃣ Melt butter in a pan over low heat. Add onion, leek, and bacon and cook until soft but not browned.
    3️⃣ Stir in the flour, cooking for 1 minute to make a roux.
    4️⃣ Gradually add white wine and fish stock, stirring constantly. Simmer for 5–10 minutes until thickened.
    5️⃣ Stir in cream, saffron, salt, pepper, parsley, and chopped eggs. Remove from heat.

    2️⃣ Assemble the Pie

    6️⃣ Roll out the puff pastry to 3mm (⅛in) thick. Cut a long 2cm (¾in) strip and press it onto the rim of a deep pie dish.
    7️⃣ Pour a little sauce into the dish and arrange mackerel with their heads resting on the dish’s edge.
    8️⃣ Pour over the remaining sauce.

    3️⃣ Create the Signature “Stargazing” Effect

    9️⃣ Cut a pastry lid slightly larger than the dish and make slits to fit the fish heads.
    🔟 Carefully place the pastry over the pie, threading each fish head through the slits so they “gaze” upwards.
    1️⃣1️⃣ Brush the pastry with beaten egg and bake for 40–45 minutes until golden and crisp.

    Why You Need to Try Stargazy Pie

    ✔️ A Unique Culinary Experience

    This dish is a visual masterpiece, with the golden, flaky crust contrasting against the rich, creamy filling. The saffron-infused sauce brings a luxurious depth of flavor, making it a memorable dish for special occasions.

    ✔️ A Hearty, Comforting Meal

    With fresh fish, smoky bacon, and velvety sauce, Stargazy Pie is both filling and satisfying. It’s perfect for a cold evening and pairs wonderfully with steamed greens and a crisp white wine.

    ✔️ A Piece of Living History

    Cooking this dish connects you with centuries-old traditions. Whether you’re celebrating Tom Bawcock’s Eve or simply exploring British cuisine, this pie brings heritage and storytelling to your kitchen.

    Expert Tips for the Perfect Stargazy Pie

    🔹 Use the freshest fish possible for the best flavor. If mackerel isn’t available, sardines work as a great alternative.
    🔹 Make the sauce thick enough to hold the filling together but not too heavy—it should be silky and rich without overpowering the fish.
    🔹 Don’t be afraid of the presentation—the fish heads add drama but don’t need to be eaten.
    🔹 Pair with a crisp, dry white wine (like a Cornish Sauvignon Blanc) to enhance the flavors.

    So why not bring a little history to your table and bake a Stargazy Pie today?

    🔹 Who’s up for trying this legendary dish? Let us know in the comments! 🍽️✨

    Share.

    Sam Allcock is a Business Contributor to the westportfoodfestival.ie

    Related Posts

    View 235 Comments

    235 Comments

    Leave A Reply